The Guidelines for the Handicap Trophy can be found here
A list of the winners appears below:
| 1986 | Ray Lawrence |
| 1987 | Marg Forden |
| 1988 | Dalton Moffett |
| 1989 | Dave Roberts |
| 1990 | Rob Davis |
| 1991 | Ron Sutton |
| 1992 | Brian Danby |
| 1993 | Ian Colquhoun |
| 1994 | Ted Maslen |
| 1995 | Milton Mavrick |
| 1996 | Merv Jones |
| 1997 | Stuart Parkinson |
| 1998 | Alan Jennings |
| 1999 | Keith Atkinson |
| 2000 | Graham Thornton |
| 2001 | Mike Hale |
| 2002 | Rod Tinniswood |
| 2003 | John Bell |
| 2004 | Jim Barnes |
| 2005 | Helen Lysaght |
| 2006 | Mike Rhodes |
| 2007 | Lachlan Marr |
| 2008 | David Carr |
| 2009 | Ray Hall |
| 2010 | Richard Danks |
| 2011 | Melissa Hynds |
| 2012 | Vic Waters |
| 2013 | Bob Schickert |
| 2014 | Milton Mavrick |
| 2015 | John Fisher |
| 2016 | Keith Atkinson |
| 2017 | Bob Schickert |
| 2018 | Elizabeth Gomez |
| 2019 | John Fisher |
| 2020 | Cancelled |
| 2021 | Rashanti Wanigasekera & Zane Walsh |
| 2022 | Rodney Glossop |
| 2023 | Crystal Glossop |